DMARC support in Wild Apricot emails
SPF alignment requires the Return-Path: to match our custom domain. Alas, WA forces it to account@wildapricot.org, causing 100% SPF failure. Amazon SES solves this with "Mail From Domain" settings, which require us setting the proper DNS records to have a subdomain MX to SES and they get their bounces this way and we get SPF management.
At present we're having a lot of SPAM/silent deletions of our emails due to SPF misalignment (We are 100% DKIM aligned), and this would help that issue.
Syd Weinstein
shared this idea
Implemented as part of 8.5 release https://gethelp.wildapricot.com/en/articles/2011-version-8-5-0-release
-
Ed W
commented
Same here...
-
Darren
commented
From Postmark DMARC:
"memberlodge.org is authorized to send on behalf of ---.org, however it looks like SPF is still failing DMARC’s alignment test. DMARC looks at the Return-Path of a message to make sure the domain there matches the domain in your From address. If the Return-Path path doesn’t match your From address, those messages will fail DMARC’s SPF alignment test. Check with this source because you may need to set up a custom Return-Path."
-
Darren
commented
As far as I understand a custom return-path is not implemented, which is what this idea is seeking.
More info can be found here - https://support.dmarcdigests.com/article/1196-how-to-set-up-a-return-path
-
Darren
commented
Oleg any updates on this? We are failing DMARC’s SPF alignment test due to the Return-Path path not matching our From address.
-
Roger Brooks
commented
We too have a lot of mail to members marked as spam, delivered to spam folders or even just deleted despite correct DKIM and SPF implementation.
This will only get more and more important as people (and organizations) get more security-conscious!P.S. Since Syd Weinstein talks about an address at wildapricot.org, I presume he doesn't have his own domain. We do, but the lack of DMARC support is still a problem, as is the lack of flexibility in DKIM and SPF!
-
This will be addressed when we implement DMARC support for Wild Apricot emails. This is on our radars now, but no exact plans.
I'll post updates about it as we have any
